Alan Menken: How Disney Music Learned to Work on Broadway

Alan Menken at the piano performing music from his Disney and Broadway career

Alan Menken: How Disney Music Learned to Work on Broadway

The Disney Composer Who Had to Teach Broadway How a Cartoon Could Breathe

On April 18, 1994, Disney did something it had never done before. Beauty and the Beast opened at Broadway’s Palace Theatre as Disney’s first Broadway musical. It would ultimately play 5,464 performances, remaining on Broadway until July 29, 2007.

But Alan Menken faced a peculiar problem. The music had already worked. Millions of people already knew “Belle,” “Be Our Guest” and “Beauty and the Beast” from the 1991 animated film. Menken and Howard Ashman’s score had already won Academy Awards. Broadway did not need Menken simply to write another successful collection of songs. It needed him to solve something much harder: how do you take music written for animation—where a cut can move instantly from a village street to a castle, and a teapot can sing without explanation—and rebuild it so that living performers can sustain the same world eight times a week?

That problem would eventually help change not only Menken’s career. It would help establish a production model through which Disney animation could become live musical theatre.


Before Disney, There Was a Plant

A group photo of cast and crew members posing together in front of a large puppet resembling a plant with a wide open mouth, reminiscent of a musical production, set against a theatrical backdrop.

Menken’s Disney career makes more sense if we begin somewhere less obvious. A small Off-Broadway theatre. And a carnivorous plant. Little Shop of Horrors, created by Menken and lyricist Howard Ashman, opened Off-Broadway in 1982. The show demonstrated something that would become fundamental to their later work: songs could move quickly between character, comedy and story without stopping the dramatic machinery.

When Ashman later called Menken about joining Disney’s The Little Mermaid, Menken saw the project partly as a reunion with his former collaborator. On his official site, he describes The Little Mermaid as essentially their follow-up to Little Shop of Horrors. That connection matters. Disney did not simply acquire a composer who could write melodies. It acquired a songwriting partnership already trained in musical dramaturgy. Songs had jobs. They introduced characters. They established desire. They accelerated action. They changed relationships. And that approach would become one of the foundations of Disney’s modern musical language.


Alan Menken Had Never Scored a Film

Here is the surprising part. When Menken began The Little Mermaid, he had never written a film score. He learned while doing it. Menken’s own account says that The Little Mermaid marked the beginning of his career as a film-score composer. The result brought him Academy Awards for both Original Score and “Under the Sea.”

But the awards obscure the production lesson. Animation gave Menken something theatre never could: absolute control over time. A film can cut. Compress. Repeat. Move locations instantly. Synchronize an image precisely to a musical beat. If an animated character needs to land on a note, animators can construct the visual event around the music.

Live theatre reverses part of that relationship. Bodies get tired. Scenery requires time to move. Costumes need changing. Performers breathe. Audiences react at slightly different speeds. Technical cues have physical consequences. Music therefore cannot merely accompany theatrical machinery. It has to help organize it. Menken would eventually have to learn his own songs again—this time as stage architecture.


Then Howard Ashman Told Him the Truth

The story behind Beauty and the Beast carries another layer. While Menken and Ashman were writing its songs, Ashman was seriously ill. Menken has recalled that Ashman initially kept his health condition secret; the night they won their Oscars for The Little Mermaid, Ashman told him he’d been diagnosed with HIV back in 1988, midway through that film’s production. Ashman died from AIDS-related complications on March 14, 1991, at age 40, before Beauty and the Beast was released.

Menken later wrote that the score remains inseparable in his mind from Ashman’s final period and the emotional pressure surrounding their work. That gives the familiar title song a different context. The music that would eventually become one of Disney’s most reusable theatrical assets was created during an intensely personal loss. And Menken would later have to expand that musical world without the collaborator who had helped define its language.


The Film Was Finished. Broadway Wasn’t.

A smiling musician playing a piano on stage, wearing a beige jacket and glasses, with colorful stage lights in the background.

When Disney decided to turn Beauty and the Beast into a stage musical, simply transferring the film songs would not create a complete theatrical score. A film and a Broadway musical require different musical structures. The original Broadway production credited Alan Menken (music), Howard Ashman (lyrics), Tim Rice (additional lyrics), Linda Woolverton (book), Michael Kosarin (musical direction), Danny Troob (orchestrations) and David Friedman (vocal arrangements).

This list is important. Audiences often reduce a musical to “music and lyrics.” Production does not work that way. A melody written at a piano has to become playable by an orchestra. Vocal arrangements have to support characters and ensemble. Dance arrangements must accommodate choreography. Underscore has to bridge dramatic transitions. Scene changes need musical time. Entrances need timing. Exits need timing. Applause can change timing. A score becomes infrastructure.


A Two-Minute Film Transition Can Become a Stage Problem

Imagine the fundamental difference. In animation, Belle leaves one location. Cut. She is somewhere else. Onstage, the first location may still physically exist. A scenic unit must move. Another must arrive. Actors may need to exit through one path while others enter through another. Props must clear. Lighting has to redirect attention so that the audience looks where the production wants them to look.

This is where music becomes a powerful production tool. Underscore can hide mechanical time. A musical phrase can motivate movement. A reprise can allow a costume change. An orchestral transition can make a scenic transition feel like storytelling rather than waiting. The audience hears continuity. Backstage, departments are buying seconds. That is one of the least visible functions of theatrical composition.


“Be Our Guest” Had to Become Physical

Consider “Be Our Guest.” Animation can create an unlimited army of objects. Plates can fly. Candles can multiply. Perspective can change instantly. The camera can travel wherever the animators want. Broadway has none of those freedoms. Every visible object must be solved physically or theatrically.

The original Broadway production brought together Robert Jess Roth’s direction, Matt West’s choreography, Stan Meyer’s scenery, Ann Hould-Ward’s costumes, Natasha Katz’s lighting, T. Richard Fitzgerald’s sound and Wendall K. Harrington’s projection effects. Now Menken’s music had another job. It had to support a production number made of actual performers occupying actual space. The score becomes a grid. Choreography attaches to it. Lighting attaches to it. Scenic cues attach to it. Effects attach to it. Comedy attaches to it. A musical number that looked spontaneous in animation becomes a precisely scheduled live event. Yet the audience must never feel the schedule.

The Orchestra Is Part of the Scenic Machinery

A vibrant theatrical scene featuring a line of performers in colorful costumes, each striking a playful pose with exaggerated expressions, against a richly decorated stage backdrop with stained glass elements.

This is where Menken’s contribution becomes particularly interesting for IMMERSIVE LAB. We usually think of scenery as something we see. But music can perform many of the same functions. Scenery tells us where we are. Music can do that. Lighting changes atmosphere. Music can do that. Automation changes physical energy. Music can prepare us for that change before it happens. A composer therefore participates in audience navigation.

Menken’s scores are especially effective at establishing readable worlds quickly. The opening of “Belle” does not require a lengthy explanation of the village. Rhythm, melodic repetition, ensemble voices and character entrances construct social geography. We understand that Belle is inside a community. We understand that the community watches her. We understand that she does not fit comfortably within it. Music has effectively built the village before scenery has finished telling us what it looks like.


One Missing Song Reveals the Difference Between Film and Stage

The Broadway adaptation also recovered material that demonstrates how a song can acquire a different function when moved between media. “Human Again,” written by Menken and Ashman for the animated film, had been removed during the movie’s development. For the stage version, the song returned.

That is not merely a restored musical number. Its theatrical usefulness is different. Onstage, enchanted objects are portrayed by performers. Those characters possess bodies. The audience spends time watching them. Their desire to become human again can therefore support ensemble characterization while expanding the emotional stakes of the castle. Theatre gives the material a different kind of presence. A discarded film song can become valuable because the medium has changed the production problem.


April 18, 1994 — Disney Enters Broadway

When Beauty and the Beast officially opened at the Palace Theatre, Disney was not yet the Broadway institution audiences now take for granted. The production received nine Tony nominations, including Best Musical and Best Original Score. Ann Hould-Ward won for Costume Design—the show’s only competitive Tony win that year.

But the longer-term result was more consequential than the awards. The show ran for more than thirteen years and 5,464 performances. That meant the experiment was no longer an experiment. A Disney animated musical had demonstrated that its musical storytelling could survive translation into a long-running live production. The implications were enormous.


But Menken’s Stage Formula Was Never Just “Put the Movie on Broadway”

A woman in a blue and white period costume sits pensively on a chair, gazing into the distance, with a decorative lamp beside her against a colorful backdrop.

That becomes obvious when we look at what followed. The Little Mermaid reached Broadway in 2008. Aladdin opened at the New Amsterdam Theatre in 2014. Newsies followed a stranger trajectory: the 1992 film had performed poorly at the box office, but later developed an audience through home viewing before becoming a major stage property. Menken himself describes the film’s initial failure and its later transformation into a Broadway success. That is an important contradiction. Theatre adaptation does not simply preserve a successful movie. It can re-engineer material that previously failed.


Aladdin Had Already Been Rebuilt Once Before Broadway

The history of Aladdin makes this especially clear. Menken and Ashman originally created a substantially different version of the film’s song score for an early story treatment. Menken says that version was shelved during development. When the project re-emerged, only “Friend Like Me” and “Arabian Nights” remained from it. “Prince Ali” came shortly before Ashman’s death. Menken then began a new collaboration with Tim Rice, which produced “One Jump Ahead” and “A Whole New World.”

Think about what that means. One of Disney’s most familiar musical scores was not the inevitable result of a smooth creative process. It emerged through rejection. Removal. Rewriting. A collaborator’s death. A new lyricist. Story changes. And reconstruction. That is production development. The finished score hides its scars.


Broadway Opened the Archive

A woman in a golden yellow ball gown stands next to a man dressed as a beast, featuring horns and a furry face, on a stage with colorful lights in the background.

When Aladdin was adapted for Broadway, the creative team could return to material from the earlier development history. Menken’s official account notes that the Broadway production included five songs from the film as well as additional material created for the stage.

This is another useful lesson. An adaptation can become an archaeological project. Songs discarded from one version may suddenly solve problems in another. Characters can regain material. Story structures can expand. The composer is no longer simply adapting a film. He is working with an archive of possible versions. That is a very different creative process from writing a score from zero.


Alan Menken’s Real Instrument Is Not the Piano

Menken is usually described as a composer. Correctly. But from a production perspective, his most important instrument may be structure. Consider the collaborators across his career: Howard Ashman. Tim Rice. Stephen Schwartz. Glenn Slater. Jack Feldman. David Zippel. Lynn Ahrens. Different lyricists. Different stories. Different directors. Different media. Yet Menken’s music repeatedly has to solve the same larger problem: how does a song move an audience from one dramatic state to another? That is why his work transfers so effectively between screen and stage. The melody is memorable. But underneath the melody is a mechanism.


Eight Oscars Tell Only Half the Story

Menken has won eight Academy Awards—more than any other living composer, according to his official biography. That is an extraordinary statistic. It is also not the most interesting way to measure his impact on live performance. Awards record individual achievements. Production systems reveal influence.

Menken’s songs have had to survive: animation, live-action film, Broadway, West End, touring, regional productions, school productions, concert presentations, and new adaptations created decades after the original works. A song capable of surviving all those environments has something more than popularity. It has structural durability.


What Happens When a Song Outlives Its Original Technology?

A man and woman sitting on a flying carpet, dressed in elaborate costumes against a starry night sky with a large moon.

This question becomes increasingly relevant. The animation technology behind The Little Mermaid belonged to 1989. The visual technology of Beauty and the Beast belonged to 1991. Aladdin belonged to 1992. Stage technology has changed dramatically since then. Projection has changed. Automation has changed. Lighting has changed. Sound reinforcement has changed. LED systems have changed. Yet audiences still recognize the songs immediately. That gives producers enormous freedom. The physical production can be rebuilt. The musical identity remains. In that sense, Menken’s music operates almost like a theatrical operating system. New visual hardware can be installed around it.


The Composer Does Not Control the Whole Machine

There is an important caution here. It would be wrong to attribute Disney’s theatrical transformation to Alan Menken alone. Howard Ashman’s dramaturgical influence was fundamental. Tim Rice helped extend unfinished material after Ashman’s death. Linda Woolverton adapted Beauty and the Beast for the stage. Directors, choreographers, orchestrators, arrangers, designers, musical directors, performers and producers transformed compositions into physical productions. Even Beauty and the Beast’s original Broadway credits demonstrate the scale of that collaboration. Menken’s significance lies somewhere more precise. He supplied musical architecture strong enough to survive collaboration. That is harder than simply writing a memorable tune.


5,464 Performances Later

When Beauty and the Beast closed on July 29, 2007, Playbill reported on a company saying goodbye after more than thirteen years. Musical director Michael Kosarin, who had been involved since the show’s first reading, had also supervised international companies of the production.

That detail captures what Broadway success eventually becomes. The opening-night creative act turns into a maintenance system. New performers arrive. Musicians change. Costumes are repaired. Technical equipment ages. Productions transfer internationally. Standards have to be preserved. The score remains one of the primary documents holding the machine together. Every night begins again from bar one.


Editor’s Take — The Best Stage Music Buys Time Without Letting Us Feel It

A vibrant stage performance with a diverse cast dressed in colorful, sparkling costumes, depicting a lively musical scene. Central figures include a man in a blue costume and a woman in a flowing dress, surrounded by dancers celebrating with props.

Alan Menken’s contribution to theatre becomes most interesting when we stop listening only for melodies. Listen instead to what the music allows the production to do. A character crosses the stage. A costume change happens. A scenic unit disappears. Another arrives. An ensemble assembles. Lighting changes the world. A performer takes a breath. The audience never thinks: the production needed seventeen seconds. They experience continuity. That is one of musical theatre’s great invisible technologies.

Julie Taymor showed us how a visible mechanism can become part of an illusion. Idina Menzel showed how technical spectacle can become an emotional action. Kristin Chenoweth demonstrated how performance itself can operate like stage machinery. Alan Menken reveals another layer: sometimes the machine is music. A successful Broadway score does not merely accompany the production. It gives the production time to breathe. And when that architecture is strong enough, it can survive a remarkable transformation—from an animated mermaid, to a Broadway castle, to a magic carpet, to an entirely new generation of stages.

"Beauty and the Beast" cast and crew celebrating 13 years on Broadway, posing for a group photo with a banner on the stage during the final bow on July 29, 2007.

Next in LEGENDS

https://immersivelabkorea.com/elton-john-when-pop-music-entered-broadway/

References

Alan Menken — Aladdin

D23 — Beauty and the Beast

IBDB — Beauty and the Beast Original Broadway Production

Julie Taymor, Idina Menzel and Kristin Chenoweth each showed how one department could carry a production’s illusion. LEGENDS continues with the people who kept building that same theatrical language.